- Paul Kahan
Coolers serve a significant purpose in any outdoor adventure, but which is the better option for you? The most popular brand is ice bin cooler vs Yeti.
They come with high-end insulation that provides maximum cooling power to keep your food and drinks cold all day long. On the other hand, ice bin coolers have their benefits too.
These are smaller than Yeti hard coolers and cheaper; this leaves more room in your budget for other outdoor essentials like fishing gear or camping equipment. Read our blog post to see if an ice bin hard cooler is suitable for you!
Ice Bin Cooler Review
Ice Bin is a good choice as a primary or secondary cooler. Its most valuable asset is the extra space it provides compared to the other popular brands, like Yeti Tundra (which are very expensive).
Its main drawback is that when complete, it’s heavy! I would not recommend this icebox if you need to carry it more than a short distance (like the boat or car).
If you’re willing to pay a little more than a YETI Tundra and can afford it, I would recommend this soft cooler.
Yeti Cooler Review
Yeti’s coolers are manufactured by Pelican cases, one of the top brands in outdoor-recreation equipment.
There are numerous estimates on the Internet of the number of Yeti and other high-end coolers produced each year. Some sources say 3,000, while another says there is a production capacity of up to 52,000 units per month! I’ve not found an official source for either figure.
Yeti is the most expensive cooler of all. Pelican coolers are about double the cost of the Ice Bin above, but Yeti hard coolers can be as much as four times more costly than an Ice Bin!
Should you consider a cheaper cooler than YETI?
It depends on whether you can afford to spend that much for a soft cooler. If you want the absolute best, then yes!
Ice Bin Cooler vs. Yeti: What Is Difference?
Yeti hard coolers bottle openers are more expensive than the Ice Bin. They are more prominent in all dimensions and have more components (handles and latches) that the Ice Bin soft cooler lacks.
Yeti hard coolers also have rubber feet on each corner for stability, while the Ice Chest has a round plastic base that is vulnerable to twisting and warping when you set it down.
Yeti coolers have thicker walls than the Ice Chest cooler bottle openers, which means more insulation (and heavier!).
Ice Bin quart Cooler has one long cylindrical handle that makes it easy to carry, sometimes with both hands.
Yeti Cooler has two handles (at the top of each end), providing a more versatile grip. With Yeti, you can easily carry it like a backpack. This is very handy when hiking or bringing together with other gear.
Ice Bin Cooler has a latch on only one side, convenient for right-handed people but not so suitable for lefties. The latch is similar to Pelican’s latches – it can be released with one hand by pushing a button-up and pulling the handle down. Yeti hard coolers have latched on each side, making them easier to open for both right-handed and left-handed users.
I’ll quote the manufacturer’s specification here: “The Ice Bin holds 2″ of ice on average – that means you can keep your food frozen for up to 4 days”. This is similar to Yeti’s claim of 3-5 days.
There are many factors involved in determining how long ice will last, including the initial temperature of the food, ambient temperature (direct sunlight is a significant factor), and even humidity.
The Ice Bin’s performance matches that of most other coolers on average. It may be more reliable than cheaper models since it has inner linings of foam, but it’s not as reliable as Yeti or Pelican.
Yeti has an advantage over the Ice Bin in that they offer a dry-ice compatible version of their quart coolers – for those who want to use dry ice regularly.
Weighing 24 lbs (11 kg), the Ice Bin is lighter than the Yeti in both the 35 and 45 models – which weighs 40 lbs (18 kg) and 50 lbs (23 kg), respectively.
The Ice Bin is wider than Yeti’s latest coolers, but it has less height (the depth is similar to the Yeti). This means that your food can be stored deeper inside the Ice Bin. Smaller items are easier to reach inside the Ice Bin.
For most consumers, we think it’s a better choice for capacity.
- Best Yeti Cooler Brand
- What Cooler Is Comparable To Yeti
- Best Coolers For The Money
- Best Wheeled Cooler
- Best Backpack Cooler
Mobility and durability: which is best?
The Ice Bin has more rubberized feet than Yeti hard coolers. This will protect the surface where you place your quart cooler from scratches and dents. Also, the Ice Bin has a round base, while Yeti Tundra coolers have square bases. This is good for stability and prevents accidental twisting of the hard cooler when you place it down.
Yeti Tundra coolers use more plastic components (such as latches) than others on the market. This allows them to build lighter models but also means that they may crack easier. So far, there have been no reports of Yeti Tundra coolers breaking in the field.
The Ice Bin has only one size: 20 gallons (76 liters) which is $409.95 from Amazon.
Yeti offers many sizes from 35 to 120 gallons. Most are around twice the cost of the Ice Bin.
What cooler is better than a yeti?
YETI hard coolers are probably the most durable and highest quality on the market, but they’re expensive. Of course, you get what you pay for.
The Ice Bin is more of a compromise between cost and size, quality, durability, etc. It’s better than the cheaper coolers on the market but falls short of the quality and function of YETI.
How long will dry ice last in a Yeti?
It depends on how you store your dry ice. It’s best not to keep it directly inside the cooler bottle opener with your food – especially if you’re using the intelligent lids that come with YETI.
Will dry ice ruin a cooler?
It can damage the plastic components (such as hinges) inside your cooler, but it depends on how long you store it in there. It could freeze your food if you’re not careful. So make sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions before using dry ice in your YETI cooler bottle opener.
Do Yeti Coolers keep ice longer?
Other than YETI’s word, there are no scientific tests that confirm this. However, many people have reported ice lasting 4 – 5 days in their YETI Tundra coolers when stored in optimal conditions (in the shade with a consistent temperature just above freezing).
Publican Anker has been helping people buy the best refrigerators for years, and we’re confident that our research can help you make a great choice. Take some time to consider your needs, what features are most important to you (or your family), and how much money is in your budget before deciding which refrigerator will be right for you.
We offer many options at every price point. There should be something out there that meets these criteria. Let us know if this article was helpful or have any other questions by reaching out on social media! So, Publican Anker high recommends Yeti as the best choice for your summer.